Blog

In the shadow of the giants like Cohiba and Montecristo, quietly resting in humidors around the world, lies a cigar that many consider to be one of Havana’s best-kept secrets: the Punch Punch. This isn’t a cigar that shouts for attention with flashy marketing or an extravagant price tag. Instead, it earns its legendary status through decades of consistent delivery, complex flavor, and remarkable aging potential.

For those in the know, the Punch Punch is a benchmark cigar—a classic medium-bodied smoke that represents the very heart of the Cuban character. This Punch Punch Cuban cigar review will delve into why this vitola has been a favorite among connoisseurs since its release in the 1960s and why it deserves a spot in your rotation.

Vital Stats: The Hermosos No. 4

• Brand: Punch

• Vitola: Hermosos No. 4

• Size: 5 5/8 inches (143mm) x 46 Ring Gauge

• Factory Name: Hermosos No. 4

• Strength: Medium-Bodied

• Smoke Time: 60-75 minutes

The Hermosos No. 4 is a classic Cuban cigar vitola known for its elegant, slightly longer format than a standard Robusto. It provides a perfect canvas for flavor development.

First Impressions: Appearance and Construction

The Punch Punch presents itself with a quiet confidence. The wrapper is a lovely Colorado brown, with a slight oily sheen and minimal veining. It is firm to the touch with no soft spots, a testament to its typically excellent Cuban construction.

The band is iconic and simple: a red and gold depiction of Punchinello (Punch) from the classic Punch and Judy puppet show, giving the brand its name. It’s a nod to the brand’s long and storied history, dating back to 1840.

The pre-light aroma is of classic Cuban earth, cedar, and a slight sweet hay. The cold draw is perfect with just the right amount of resistance, offering flavors of sweet wood and a hint of raisins.

Tasting Notes: A Journey of Complexity

First Third:

The initial puffs are a revelation of balance. There’s no aggressive pepper blast here. Instead, you are greeted with a smooth, creamy blend of cedar, sweet nuts (almonds, cashews), and a distinct honey-like sweetness. The smoke is incredibly smooth and aromatic. The draw is flawless, producing voluminous clouds of cool, flavorful smoke. This is exactly what makes Cuban cigars for beginners and experts alike so appealing—immediate, approachable flavor without compromise.

Second Third:

As the cigar progresses, the profile deepens beautifully. The core creamy and nutty notes remain, but are now joined by richer flavors of leather, baking spices (cinnamon), and a touch of dark coffee. The sweetness evolves from honey to a more demerara sugar quality. The strength remains a steady medium, never threatening to overwhelm the palate. The burn line is razor-sharp, requiring no touch-ups.

Final Third:

The last act introduces a wonderful, subtle shift. The spice notes become slightly more pronounced, with a very mild white pepper joining the cinnamon. The core profile holds strong, with the coffee and leather notes taking a more prominent role. The sweetness fades slightly, leaving a long, satisfying finish of cedar and warm nuts. It smokes cool to the very nub, a sign of its superior construction.

Strength & Body: The Goldilocks of Habanos

The Punch Punch is the absolute definition of a medium-bodied Cuban cigar. It possesses ample flavor to be deeply satisfying for the experienced smoker, yet its smoothness and lack of peppery aggression make it an ideal choice for a beginner looking to move beyond the mildest smokes.

It’s the perfect cigar for when you want more substance than a Hoyo de Monterrey but less power than a Bolivar or Partagas. It’s a cigar you can smoke any time of day without it dominating your palate.

Aging Potential: Where It Becomes Legendary

While delicious young, the Punch Punch is truly an investment cigar. It has a legendary reputation for aging as well as, if not better than, any other cigar from Cuba.

• Short-Term (1-3 years): The youthful sweetness and cedar are forward and delightful.

• Medium-Term (5-7 years): The flavors meld together, becoming incredibly smooth and integrated. The spicy notes soften, and more complex caramel and roasted nut flavors emerge.

• Long-Term (10+ years): Becomes a sublime experience. It transforms into a incredibly rich, smooth, and complex smoke with deep notes of leather, cedar chest, and sweet tea. An aged Punch Punch is a true treasure.

To realize this aging potential, proper storage is non-negotiable. Whether in a seasoned humidor or using a short-term method like how to store Cuban cigars without a humidor, *keeping your cigars at 65-68% RH is key.*

The Verdict: Who Is The Punch Punch For?

The Punch Punch is not the most famous cigar, but it is arguably one of the most complete.

• For the Beginner: It is a perfect second or third cigar. It teaches what a classic, medium-bodied Cuban profile is all about without any harshness.

• For the Connoisseur: It is a benchmark of the Hermosos No. 4 vitola. Its aging potential and consistent quality make it a box-worthy purchase for any serious collector.

• For the Value-Seeker: It often sits at a more accessible price point than other marcas’ flagship vitolas, offering incredible value for the quality of the experience.

Punch Punch vs. The World

It’s impossible not to compare it to its peers in the same vitola category. The Punch Punch stands out for its unique balance:

• It has more flavor and depth than a Montecristo No. 4.

• It is less intense and more approachable than a Partagas Serie D No. 4.

• It offers a different, more nutty profile than the creamy H. Upmann Magnum 46.

It doesn’t seek to dethrone these giants; it simply stands proudly beside them as an equal, if not an superior option for those who value balance over power.

Final Word: The Punch Punch is the definition of an underrated classic. It is a cigar that prioritizes the smoking experience above all else. It is consistently excellent, complex enough to be engaging, and smooth enough to be enjoyed by anyone. Don’t overlook this masterpiece. It may just become your new favorite daily smoke.

Before you hunt for a box, always remember the first rule of buying Habanos: authenticity. Protect your investment by learning how to identify real Cuban cigars to ensure you’re getting the genuine article.