Blog

In the pantheon of Cuban cigars, two names consistently rise to the top of every aficionado’s must-smoke list: the Montecristo No. 2 and the Partagas Serie D No. 4. These aren’t just cigars; they are institutions. They represent the pinnacle of their respective marcas and are often the first two cigars people think of when considering a premium Habano.

But if you could only choose one, which should it be? This isn’t a question of which is “better,” but which is better for you.

This head-to-head comparison will break down every aspect of these two legendary cigars—from their flavor profiles and construction to their ideal smoking occasions—so you can decide which champion deserves a place in your humidor.

Tale of the Tape: The Contenders

First, let’s meet the competitors.

Round 1: Flavor Profile & Strength

This is the most significant differentiator and will likely decide the winner for you.

Montecristo No. 2: The Refined Connoisseur

The Montecristo No. 2 is the quintessential medium-bodied Cuban cigar. It’s known for its elegant, complex, and nuanced flavor journey.

• First Third: Begins with creamy, nutty, and woody notes. A signature toasted almond and hay quality is often present.

• Second Third: Develops into a more complex profile of leather, mild spice, and a touch of citrusy sweetness.

• Final Third: The flavors deepen, often introducing coffee and cocoa notes, but it rarely becomes overpowering.

• Overall: Smooth, balanced, and incredibly aromatic. It’s a cigar that reveals its secrets slowly and rewards patience.

Partagas Serie D No. 4: The Bold Powerhouse

The Partagas Serie D No. 4 is a medium to full-bodied smoke that is unapologetically bold and rich from the first puff.

• First Third: Hits the palate immediately with rich earth, black pepper, espresso, and a distinct woody spice.

• Second Third: The core flavors intensify, with notes of dark chocolate, cedar, and a lingering peppery finish.

• Final Third: Remains robust and earthy, often with a savory, almost salty quality that is unique to Partagas.

• Overall: Direct, powerful, and satisfyingly rich. It’s a flavor bomb for those who want their cigar to make a statement.

Winner: This round is a draw. The winner is entirely dependent on your mood. Choose Montecristo for complexity and elegance; choose Partagas for power and richness.

Round 2: Construction & Draw

Both cigars are flagship vitolas for their brands and are typically constructed superbly. However, their shapes present different challenges.

• Montecristo No. 2 (Piramides): The tapered figurado shape is harder to roll perfectly. A well-made No. 2 will have a perfect draw that opens up as you smoke. A poorly made one can have a tight draw initially. A precise cut is required to avoid unraveling the tapered head.

• Partagas Serie D No. 4 (Robusto): The straight-sided parejo shape is simpler to construct consistently. The D No. 4 is famously reliable, offering a consistently excellent draw and an even burn from light to nub.

Winner: Partagas Serie D No. 4. Due to its simpler Robusto shape, it wins on consistency and reliability of construction.

If you’re new to cutting complex shapes, our guide on how to cut and light a Cuban cigar is essential reading before tackling a Montecristo No. 2.

Round 3: Occasion & Smoke Time

When and where you smoke matters.

• Montecristo No. 2: This is a special occasion cigar. At 90+ minutes, it demands your time and attention. It’s perfect for a leisurely afternoon, a celebratory dinner, or any moment where you can sit back and focus on its evolving flavor profile.

• Partagas Serie D No. 4: This is the ultimate daily luxury or “anytime” smoke. At 60-75 minutes, it fits perfectly into an evening relaxation session. Its bold flavor is also robust enough to pair with a strong drink after a meal.

Winner: Partagas Serie D No. 4. It wins on versatility. The Montecristo No. 2 is a commitment; the Partagas D4 is a readily available pleasure.

Round 4: Value & Accessibility

• Montecristo No. 2: As one of the most famous cigars in the world, it commands a premium price. It is also more susceptible to price hikes and shortages.

• Partagas Serie D No. 4: While not cheap, it often represents a slightly better value for money. It is produced in massive quantities and is generally easier to find in stock at retailers.

Winner: Partagas Serie D No. 4. It wins on better value and slightly easier availability.

The Verdict: Which One is For You?

You Should Smoke the Montecristo No. 2 if:

• You have 90+ minutes to dedicate to your cigar.

• You appreciate subtlety, complexity, and a slowly evolving flavor profile.

• You are celebrating a major milestone.

• You prefer a medium-bodied, smoother smoke.

• You already have a well-stocked humidor and are looking for a classic experience.

You Should Smoke the Partagas Serie D No. 4 if:

• You want a bold, rich, and immediately satisfying flavor punch.

• You have about an hour to smoke.

• You value consistency and reliability in construction.

• You’re pairing with a strong spirit like whiskey or rum.

• You’re building a collection and want a cornerstone Robusto that never disappoints.

Both of these cigars are fantastic examples of their vitolas. Learn more about these shapes in our complete Cuban cigar vitolas guide.*

Pro Tip: Storage is Key

Both of these cigars benefit immensely from proper aging. A young Partagas D4 can be exceptionally strong, and a young Montecristo No. 2 might not show its full complexity. Allowing them to rest in your humidor for at least a year will meld the flavors and create a significantly smoother smoking experience.

If you’re waiting for your humidor to arrive, learn how to store Cuban cigars without a humidor to keep these gems in perfect condition in the meantime.

Final Puff

The Montecristo No. 2 vs. Partagas Serie D No. 4 debate has no true loser—only two winners that cater to different preferences.

• The Montecristo No. 2 is the elegant, complex symphony.

• The Partagas Serie D No. 4 is the powerful, rich rock anthem.

Your perfect choice depends entirely on the music you want to hear today. The true sign of an aficionado is having both in their humidor, ready for whatever occasion arises.

Before you hunt for either, arm yourself with knowledge. The popularity of these cigars makes them prime targets for counterfeiting. Our essential guide on how to identify real Cuban cigars will ensure your investment is authentic.